Tuesday, April 19, 2005

Don't treat us like we treat you

Following years of crushing politicians and others for sport, the news media has now found itself getting a dose of its own medicine, and it doesn't like it.

On Monday Howard Kurtz's column (When Blogs Bite Back) was a collection of news media mainly complaining about the email they receive regarding their work. Granted it is a lot easier to send a nasty email than a letter, or write a blog, but has the world changed that much or is it just easier to scream today?

If the public's reaction has become nastier, the increasingly caustic nature of online criticism is the result of the Rushification or Coulterization of the Internet. Rush, Coulter and others have attacked politicians and others and today many bloggers are merely following the example of Hate Radio, except their target is now the media.

And now Time magazine has chosen Coulter to be its poster girl for this week's issue. Too often the punditocracy thinks its neat to feature people like Coulter and Limbaugh, no matter the damage they are doing to the public discourse. And people like Kurtz, after promoting Limbaugh (He's so mainstream that those right-wingers Tom Brokaw and Tim Russert had him on their Election Night coverage) don't understand why there's a problem.

So when will Michael Moore become a fixture as a election night commentator on the major networks?

If reporters don’t like being questioned by bloggers perhaps they should stop giving them so much ammunition. From the Post’s John Harris “Mr. Bush Catches a Washington Break,” to Jane Hall’s Columbia Journalism Review article showing how the press trashed Al Gore in 2000, to Mark Halperin’s criticism that the press shouldn’t ARTIFICALLY hold both campaigns equally accountable, to Dan Fromkin recent criticism of the press pool questions of Bush on Air Force One, readers are left with the impression that even journalists think there’s something wrong with today’s coverage.

Everyone is going to occasionally make factual mistakes. But the bigger problem is the approach one takes to the story, who is quoted, who is not, what stories are covered and which aren’t.

Now there’s no need for ugliness in reviewing this but the blogosphere is a reflection of today’s political environment, which in large part was created by another new media – talk radio.

No comments: